
Content warning: this review discusses trauma and sexual assault.
Full disclosure: I was given a free advance reader copy of this book by the author in exchange for an honest review.
You know what I haven’t read in awhile? A time travel romance! The last one I read was Transcendence by Shay Savage, which involved a caveman. This time I wanted something different. Luckily, I finished one that involves time travel to prevent climate change. What was that book called? It’s The 23rd Hero by Rebecca Anne Nguyen. It had great worldbuilding and a memorable main character although I had issues with certain plot points and the overall structure.
The 23rd Hero is about an ordinary woman with an extraordinary memory who travels back in time to sixteenth century France to stop climate change before it starts and return to the man she loves. In a world ravaged by climate change, a mysterious time travel agency called The Program sends carefully selected Heroes back in time on missions to prevent environmental damage from occurring. Sloane Burrows longs to be a Hero and restore the natural world from her childhood – a place that she can recall vividly because of her powerful memory. However, her father made her believe that her “freak memory” was shameful and that it should be hidden from the world. She buries her dreams of becoming a Hero and conceals her memory to the point of making her sick. Her only break from the shame is the recurring dream that she’s been having for a decade. In it, a beautiful man makes her feel accepted in a way that she never has experienced before, not despite her memory, but because of it. When that man, named Bastian, shows up in the real world, Sloane’s life turns upside down. It also turns out that Bastian is from The Program, and he wants her to do the one thing that will shatter her chances of winning her father’s love: become a Hero, travel back to sixteenth century France, and use her superpower memory to save the world.
Let’s start off with the good. I loved the world building in The 23rd Hero. Nguyen does a great job with establishing the dystopian place that Sloane lives in. It reminded me of the districts in The Hunger Games series, with more technology. I especially love the descriptions of the sight and smell of smog. Additionally, the time travel in the novel is fascinating. I have read and watched stuff that deals with that trope, but The 23rd Hero takes it in a whole new direction. Usually, when people go back in time, it’s usually to see what the past was like and stop whatever is going to alter the timeline (ie Doctor Who). In this case, the objective is to deliberately change the past, so the future would be better environmentally. The Program sends one Hero to stop something that would result in climate change. If something else occurs as a result, they can send another to fix that. While there isn’t much logic surrounding the time travel, there’s enough for readers to piece it together. It was intriguing to see it portrayed in this way.
Another plus is Sloane herself. She is one who believes that her superpower is a curse. Sloane has a wonderful memory, but anything that she has to access it reminds her of the father’s emotional abuse, and she vomits. As a result, she barely has any self-confidence despite her dreams to become a Hero. Her issue is absolutely relatable to any person who’s gone through something similar. Sloane’s romance with the mysterious man later known as Bastian helps her to build her confidence. Even though it would’ve been nice to have a bit more character development from Bastian, their chemistry is undeniable, which hurts more when Sloane has to enter the portal into 1500s France. This would no doubt remind readers of The Outlander series.
There have been people who have taken issues with certain elements of the book. One of them includes the depiction of religion. Some have said that it is used to manipulate others to spread their version of God’s word. There’s no doubt that priests in Catholic France would have done something like this to suit their view of Catholicism. My problem is that Sloane does something similar to advance the message about Mother Earth. It’s like when bad people cajole others to believe a message, it’s wrong, but when a good person does it, it’s good?
Also, at one point, one of the priests sexually assaults Sloane while he’s trying to get her to confess her sins. She is no doubt traumatized, but she deals with it by trying to have sex with another man. Many readers had a problem with it because it’s not how people should handle a situation like that. I had a similar initial thought with, “Ok…why? Wouldn’t you not want to have sex for a while after that incident?”
But, the more I thought about it, the more I realized that it makes sense for Sloane. Since she has a powerful memory, she remembers everything, both good and bad. For her, she wants to rewrite it with a better one. There are people who are like Sloane and have to have different associations with places and things. For example, I had a friend who went through a terrible break up last year. One of the places they went to was a restaurant in Grand Rapids. When I visited her, she wanted to go to that place to “erase” the memory of the dude she dated. The point is that with Sloane, wanting to have sex after experiencing sexual assault is a realistic response even if it’s not the most appropriate. After all, she makes some incredible stupid decisions, but once readers know why, it’s understandable. Plus, if every character had perfect reactions to bad things, they would be quite boring.
My main issue with The 23rd Hero is the structure. From the blurb, one would think that Sloane would spend plenty of time in sixteenth century France. Surprisingly, she doesn’t. In fact, she doesn’t actually travel through time until over halfway through the novel. The book spends a good chunk of the time on her training and her romance with Bastian, which makes sense since they all are a part of her journey. I wish that Sloane would’ve gotten to time travel sooner. It’s like what if Cinderella went to the ball in the third act as opposed to the second one. Also, once Sloane is in France, her time is brief. I wish that there was more time spent on the mission once she’s in the past. As it is, it felt underwhelming.
The 23rd Hero by Rebecca Anne Nguyen is a fine time travel romance. The first half got me invested in the world the characters live in and in Sloane. However, once the time travel happened, it kind of lost me. I wish that occurred sooner, so more time could be spent in 1500s France. I still liked it though. I would only recommend this to those love time travel romances like The Outlander series and to those who enjoy reading about characters embracing their “superpowers.” While it’s not a bad book, I think it could’ve been better. Maybe I’ll read another one that involves a caveman.
Subscribe below to get notified when I post new updates. Also feel free to email me here for any review suggestions, ideas, or new titles!
































































